Tuesday, August 7, 2012

D&D Next: Playtest Update from Mike Mearls

Mike's newest Legends and Lore gives us a nice list of things to expect in the forthcoming Open Playtest Update.

The parts I'm focusing on today are the decisions to add a Skill List and the change to Rogue Skills.

I thought it was really cool that DnD Next had ditched a fixed Skill List, it reminded me of Old School play and some newer designs, like Over the Edge, Unknown Armies and 13th Age.  When I read it, I was pretty bummed, but I can see why they made the decision.

When I was running the Open Playtest, I had to ask players to tell me if they felt a Skill applied to the situation or remember ALL of their skills.  It slowed things down, not in a huge way, but it did slow play.

I can see that calling for a Skill check from a set Skill List would help speed up play and cut down on questions like, "How is Hunter different from Scout?".

Plus, I can always ditch the Skill List and go back to Player & DM driven Skills.  I'm not sure why this is viewed as a minus these days.  While I understand that new players may be confused, sometimes I think that means we need to focus on mentoring gamers more.  I know that my experiences as a new gamer would have been stronger if my group had a mentor.

As an aside, the Closed Playtest had a Skill List.

As for Rogue Skills, the new iteration of the rules will allow Skills that Rogues are Trained in to use the better of their Ability Modifier or +3.  Apparently this is to help combat the problem of low wisdom Rogues not being able to use Find Traps.  To be clear, under this new rule a Rogue with a Wisdom of 8 would have a Find Trap Skill Rank total of +6, a +3 from Wis and a +3 for being trained; as opposed to a +2, a -1 from Wis and a +3 for being trained, under the previous rules.

First off this "problem" of low wisdom and Find Traps seemed to overlook Skill Mastery, which gave Rogues a minimum die roll of 10 on any skills they're trained in.  I think Skill Mastery is swell, by the way.

Secondly, I don't think this a terrible idea as a cool exception based mechanic, but I'm weary of too many exceptions.

Honestly, the more I contemplate it, the more I like it.  I just hope Skill Mastery doesn't go away.

I really hope the down times of WotC's website means they're gearing up for a posting the Open Playtest before Gen Con, but we'll see.

No comments:

Cinematic Monsters: The Sentinel AKA Phantasm's The Ball for Old School Essentials

The Sentinel for Old School Essentials They are spherical metal devices used by the Tall Man for various purposes, primarily enforcement. ...